Cyclic loading reduces soil resistance during pile driving by repeatedly shearing and remoulding the soil around the pile shaft, causing local shear strength to drop below its initial value. This effect is most pronounced in granular soils, where grain contact pressures can fall sharply under vibration, and in sensitive clays, where remoulding destroys the soil’s natural structure. The sections below unpack the mechanisms behind this resistance loss, the soil types most at risk, and how modern driveability analysis accounts for it.
What happens to soil resistance when cyclic loading is applied?
When cyclic loading is applied during pile driving, the repeated stress reversals progressively break down the soil structure around the pile, reducing the shear resistance available at the shaft and, to a lesser extent, at the toe. Each loading cycle displaces soil grains or remoulds clay particles, and the cumulative effect is a measurable drop in the resistance the pile must overcome to advance. This is not a sudden failure but a gradual degradation that develops blow by blow or cycle by cycle.
The total resistance a pile encounters during driving has two distinct components. Static soil resistance reflects the load-displacement relationship that also governs long-term bearing capacity. Dynamic soil resistance arises from velocity- and acceleration-dependent effects during rapid pile movement and does not contribute to static capacity. When cyclic loading degrades the static component, the pile may advance more easily during installation, but the long-term capacity picture becomes more complex and requires careful interpretation.
In vibratory driving, the continuous oscillation disrupts grain contacts in granular soils so effectively that the available shear resistance can fall to a small fraction of its initial value, allowing the pile to penetrate largely under the combined static weight of the hammer and pile. In impact driving, the same degradation mechanism operates, but it accumulates across discrete blows rather than continuous cycles.
What is cyclic degradation and how does it develop in soil?
Cyclic degradation is the progressive reduction in soil shear strength or stiffness caused by repeated loading and unloading. It develops because each cycle causes small but cumulative changes in soil fabric, pore pressure, or grain contact geometry. Over many cycles, these changes compound until the soil reaches a lower residual resistance that it can sustain without further deterioration.
The rate and severity of degradation depend on several interacting factors:
- Soil type: granular soils degrade rapidly under vibration; sensitive clays degrade when remoulded; dense sands and stiff clays are more resistant
- Cycle amplitude: larger displacement amplitudes drive the soil further into plastic behaviour, accelerating degradation
- Number of cycles: degradation accumulates with each blow or oscillation, so longer piles driven through the same soil layer experience more total cycles at any given depth
- Drainage conditions: in low-permeability soils, pore pressures build up and cannot dissipate quickly, amplifying the strength reduction
A particularly important expression of cyclic degradation in pile driving is friction fatigue, sometimes called friction degradation. As the pile tip advances past a given soil horizon, that horizon is subjected to an increasing number of load cycles from subsequent blows. Research by Alm and Hamre, based on back-analysis of offshore installations including large open steel tubular piles driven to depths of up to 115 metres, showed that local shaft friction at a given depth decreases as the pile tip moves further below that level. Close to the advancing tip, friction is relatively high; further behind the tip, it declines toward a residual value. Models that ignore this effect tend to overestimate the Soil Resistance to Driving (SRD) for long piles, sometimes by a significant margin.
Why does soil resistance sometimes decrease during pile driving?
Soil resistance decreases during pile driving because the installation process itself alters the soil conditions around the pile. The repeated mechanical disturbance remoulds soil structure, changes effective stress states, and in granular soils temporarily reduces the contact forces between grains. The result is that the resistance measured or predicted during driving can be substantially lower than the undisturbed in-situ strength would suggest.
In granular soils under vibratory driving, the cyclic displacement disrupts grain packing and reduces inter-granular contact pressure. This is sometimes associated with liquefaction, but the resistance reduction is broader than that: it occurs in unsaturated granular materials too, where true liquefaction cannot develop. The correct framing is cyclic disturbance and temporary loss of shear resistance, not liquefaction as a prerequisite.
In cohesive soils, the mechanism is different. Clay particles are remoulded by repeated shearing, destroying the natural soil fabric that gives the undisturbed material its strength. The degree of strength loss depends on the clay’s sensitivity. Highly sensitive clays can lose a large proportion of their undrained shear strength when remoulded, while low-sensitivity clays show only modest reductions.
Laboratory research on dynamic shaft friction in sand has also demonstrated that remoulding under repeated impacts changes soil resistance even when other model parameters remain constant. This confirms that the resistance during installation is not a fixed material property but a process-dependent quantity that evolves as driving progresses.
How do setup and relaxation relate to cyclic loading effects?
Setup and relaxation are the time-dependent changes in pile capacity that occur after driving stops, and both are directly connected to the disturbance caused by cyclic loading during installation. Setup is the recovery of capacity over time; relaxation is its further reduction. Understanding these effects is important because the resistance during driving and the capacity available for long-term service are related but not identical quantities.
Setup: capacity recovery after cyclic disturbance
Setup occurs when soils that lost strength during driving regain it after installation ends. In clays, remoulding during driving reduces undrained shear strength, but the disturbed soil reconsolidates and regains strength over days, weeks, or months as excess pore pressures dissipate. In granular soils, setup is generally faster and linked to the re-establishment of grain contact pressures and stress arching around the shaft. The practical consequence is that a pile tested immediately after driving will show lower capacity than the same pile tested weeks later.
Relaxation: continued resistance loss after driving
Relaxation is the opposite effect and is most common in dense sands, chalk, and certain rock-like materials. During driving, high dynamic stresses temporarily dilate or fracture the soil or rock around the pile. When driving stops, these stresses redistribute and the effective resistance available to the pile can fall below what was measured at the end of driving. Chalk is a well-documented example: driveability studies in low-to-medium density chalk must account for the possibility that end-of-drive resistance overstates long-term capacity.
Both effects underscore the point that driveability analysis and static capacity assessment address different moments in the pile’s life. The resistance during cyclic loading at installation is a starting condition, not the final answer on foundation performance.
How is cyclic loading behaviour accounted for in pile driving analysis?
Cyclic loading behaviour is accounted for in pile driving analysis by separating static and dynamic resistance components, incorporating friction fatigue into the SRD profile, and selecting soil model parameters that reflect the actual loading mechanism rather than static test conditions. Modern driveability software applies these principles within a stress-wave framework to simulate the full hammer-pile-soil interaction blow by blow.
The AllWave software package, which we develop and maintain, applies the Method of Characteristics to simulate stress-wave propagation through the pile and its interaction with the surrounding soil. Within this framework, the soil model distinguishes between spring-based static resistance, which depends on relative displacement, and velocity- and acceleration-dependent dynamic resistance. This separation prevents the common error of treating a high total driving resistance as equivalent to a high static bearing capacity.
For impact driving, AllWave-PDP generates blow count versus penetration profiles, maximum tensile and compressive stresses, energy transfer, and refusal risk assessments. Friction fatigue is incorporated by making local shaft friction a function not only of soil type at a given depth but also of the distance the pile tip has advanced below that depth. This produces SRD profiles that more accurately reflect what long piles actually encounter during offshore and onshore installation.
For vibratory driving, the physics differ fundamentally. A vibratory hammer imposes continuous cyclic displacement, velocity, and acceleration rather than discrete impact waves. The soil response under these conditions cannot be described adequately by the same simple viscous damping model used for impact driving. AllWave-VDP addresses this by applying a generalised soil reaction model that accounts for the specific loading character of vibratory installation, including the strong resistance reduction in granular soils and the amplitude-dependent behaviour in cohesive soils.
Soil parameters for both approaches are derived from available ground investigation data, including CPT, SPT, and laboratory results, and translated into the model parameters appropriate for the chosen dynamic soil model. This grounding in site-specific geotechnical data is what separates a reliable driveability prediction from a generic estimate.
What soil types are most vulnerable to cyclic resistance loss?
The soil types most vulnerable to cyclic resistance loss during pile driving are loose to medium-dense granular soils, sensitive clays, and structured or cemented materials such as chalk. Each loses resistance through a different mechanism, and each requires a different modelling approach in driveability analysis.
- Loose to medium-dense sands and gravels: grain contact pressures drop rapidly under cyclic disturbance, and the temporary resistance reduction can be very large. Vibratory driving exploits this effect deliberately, allowing the pile to advance under its own weight and the hammer’s static load.
- Sensitive clays: remoulding during driving destroys the natural soil fabric. High-sensitivity clays can lose a large fraction of their undrained shear strength during installation, though much of this recovers through setup after driving ends.
- Chalk: low-to-medium density chalk is particularly problematic because it can show high resistance during driving but lower long-term capacity due to relaxation. The cyclic crushing and fracturing of the chalk matrix during installation alters the stress state around the pile in ways that are difficult to predict without site-specific calibration.
- Lightly overconsolidated clays: these soils generate excess pore pressures under cyclic loading that dissipate slowly, sustaining the resistance reduction for longer periods after driving.
Dense sands and stiff, low-sensitivity clays are generally more resistant to cyclic degradation, though they are not immune. In dense sands, friction fatigue still operates along the shaft as the pile advances, and the cumulative effect over a long pile can still produce meaningful SRD reductions relative to a simple static friction model.
Cohesive soils also present a specific challenge for vibratory driving: because plastic deformation only occurs when the displacement amplitude exceeds the elastic threshold of the soil, a vibratory hammer with insufficient eccentric moment may produce oscillations that remain largely elastic. In that case, very little permanent penetration occurs per cycle. This is why hammer selection for cohesive soils must consider displacement amplitude, not just centrifugal force, and why vibratory driving is generally more effective in granular than in cohesive ground.
How We Help with Cyclic Loading and Driveability Analysis
We combine decades of experience in pile installation mechanics with our own software tools and geotechnical expertise to give your team a reliable picture of what the soil will do during driving, before the first blow lands.
Here is what we offer for projects where cyclic loading and driveability are a concern:
- Driveability studies using AllWave-PDP and AllWave-VDP: we simulate impact and vibratory pile installation using site-specific CPT, SPT, and laboratory data, incorporating friction fatigue, dynamic soil resistance, and pile geometry to produce blow count profiles, stress envelopes, and refusal risk assessments
- Soil model calibration: we translate your ground investigation results into the dynamic soil model parameters appropriate for your installation method, avoiding the mismatch between static capacity models and driving conditions
- Hammer selection support: we evaluate hammer options against your pile geometry and soil conditions, including eccentric moment and amplitude considerations for vibratory driving in cohesive soils
- Setup and relaxation assessment: we advise on the timing and interpretation of post-installation testing to distinguish driving resistance from long-term static capacity
- Dynamic Load Testing and signal matching: where driveability predictions need field verification, we perform and interpret DLT to validate or refine the soil model used in the prediction
If your project involves long offshore piles, challenging soil profiles, or vibratory installation in variable ground conditions, accurate modelling of cyclic resistance effects can make the difference between a reliable installation plan and costly surprises on site. Contact us to discuss your project and find out how we can support your driveability analysis.
Gerelateerde artikelen
- What makes pile driving in chalk difficult to predict?
- How can Dynamic Load Testing be used to validate a pile driving model?
- Why should lower, best-estimate and upper-bound soil resistance be analysed?
- How is the load measured with Rapid Load Testing?
- How does stand-alone data logging work during monopile installation?

